Which garage door is better, Amarr or Clopay?

Clopay is generally the better choice for premium design and the highest insulation R-values, while Amarr is the better choice for durable steel construction at a lower price. Clopay leads on design selection, Intellicore polyurethane insulation up to R-20, and premium lines like Canyon Ridge and Coachman. Amarr leads on the SafeGuard pinch-resistant panel system, the popular Classica carriage-house collection at a strong price, and the Costco partnership. Clopay typically costs 10 to 25 percent more than Amarr for a comparably equipped door. For most households, both deliver 25-plus years of reliable service when properly installed and maintained. Pick Clopay for design and energy efficiency. Pick Amarr for value, durability, and the Classica look without the wood door price.